So excited for this theme. *I also have heard from my mom that my guy David Cook totally KILLS it. So I am super excited!!* Um why is Paula wearing long black gloves?
Ramiele Malubay – 1987’s “Alone” by Heart
[Ok let me begin with saying that she is SO stupid for singing this song, no one will ever sing this better then Carrie, and it should be like retired from AI history]
The beginning is a bit wobbly. Did she change keys? Yeah she is totally singing it lower. Annnd she sounds like she is screaming. Who told her this would be a good song choice for her? Oh wow is she screaming. She tried to like change it up at the end but it just sounded awkward. I did not like the arrangement of it either, they picked weird parts of the song to put together. Randy thought it was too big for her and the wrong song choice. Paula is glad America heard her big voice, and she gives her credit. Apparently she is sick — no excuse lady. Simon didn’t think it was as bad as Randy said…HUH? He thinks she was shrieking but she will probably get thru. Ramiele sounds fine to me… no excuse!!
Jason Castro – 1987’s “Fragile” by Sting
[Aww it's his birthday today!! Happy Birthday Jason! His video was so cute]
Good to see him playing the guitar again. I don’t know this song. He sounds really good tho. This doesn’t sound like a very complicated song, but he sounds good. Is he singing in Spanish? What is with this kid singing songs in different languages? It was an OK song, nothing special or memorable but he sang it well. He needs more exciting songs. Apparently it is one of Randy’s favorite songs and he thought it was nice and pleasant. Paula thinks he is staying true to who he is but he is playing it safe. Simon thinks he has had two bad weeks and that it is time to take it more seriously. He said he potentially could win this but not if he keeps doing songs like that. Good Point Simon! hahah was he giving a peace sign or saying vote for him he is number 2
Syesha Mercado – 1987’s “If I Were Your Woman” by Stephanie Mills
[They put all three people born in 1987 in a row]
Well she sounds really good so far. Wow I am really impressed with Syesha. And we all know that I do NOT like her normally. She hasn’t screamed once, she isn’t wearing a scarf, and she is really killling this song. Her upper register sounds nice too. Very controlled song, I think it was her best performance to date. Nice job Syesha. Randy thought it was a good moment for her — best he’s ever heard her sing. Paula said this is going to be the moment where she became the dark horse. Simon said it was def. the best so far, he didn’t like the end. I still don’t really like her that much, but this was quite a great song for her.
Chikezie – 1985’s “If Only For One Night” by Luther Vandross
Oh he already messed up that first pass. Umm…this is a weird song to sing. It’s just kinda blah… I dunno? He has had some weird pitchy problems and I could NEVER imagine hearing this song on the radio. His big note was pretty good — but that was it. Meh it was ok. Randy thought it was old and he didn’t love it. Paula thought he did a great job. Simon thought he sang it well but the performance was cheesy. I agree Simon!
Brooke White – 1983’s “Every Breath You Take” by The Police
Oh wow she kinda messed up in the beginning. But she recovered nicely. I like this acoustic sounding version of the song — its quite pretty. Very nicely done. I think she needs to sing Sheryl Crow’s Are you Strong enough to be my man one day. Randy liked the first part but he didn’t love the middle he wanted her to just stay like the beginning (I agree). Paula enjoyed this performance. Simon agrees with Randy and that she should have stayed at the piano without the band.
Michael Johns – 1978’s “We Are the Champions” by Queen
Nice we start with We Will Rock You and he sounds awesome! Now into We are the Champions — awesome. This guy sounds good with Queen. Ohh a little ahead of the band there. This is his rock star moment for sure. He sounds good, he looks good, and the audience loves him. Good choice of song and great performance. Finally!!! Wow the audience is going crazy. Randy said FINALLY hahah best performance since he’s been on the show. Paula said this was his moment and she is proud of him. Simon said it’s the first time he saw star potential in this performance. And that it is the only memorable performance tonight so far. Good Job Michael!!
Carly Smithson – 1983’s “Total Eclipse of the Heart” by Bonnie Tyler
[LOVE this song, but it is kinda low in the beginning should be interesting aww she is named after Carly Simon]
She can really sing these 80 power band chick songs. This isn’t as good as her Heart song a few weeks back but she sounds really good. Ick she def cracked on the end not there but still good. Hopefully it’ll be enough to keep her out of that bottom three this week. Randy didn’t like it that much. Paula thinks she can sing anything. Simon thought something didn’t quite work. I agree she seems a bit nervous or scared *maybe bc she was in the bottom three last week*
David Archuleta – 1990’s “You’re the Voice” by David Foster
[he might miss his prom...who knows]
What is this song? Oh it’s a Christian song isn’t it? What an awkward song… He is a good singer but I like him less every week. He should have sang like “Why should I worry” by Billy Joel..I wonder when that came out. What a weird ass song. Randy thought it was a strange song choice, but if you can sing sing whatever. Paula said he can sing the phone book. Simon didn’t like the performance at all he thought it was theme parkish. He doesn’t think he picked the song himself. HA.
Kristy Lee Cook – 1984’s “God Bless the USA” by Lee Greenwood
[oh god]
She looks awful. I wonder how many times she sang this song in pageants and at the county fair. Wow super awkward key transition. I bet the band was like are you serious when they found out she was singing this song. I mean yeah I guess she sounded good but what a wacko. Randy thought it was a good song choice. Paula said pitchy but her voice is stronger. Simon thought it was her best performance by a mile. Yeah but it was LAME.
David Cook – 1983’s “Billie Jean” by Michael Jackson
[Yeah pimp spot!! Awww my mom called to tell me that David Cook and I had the same highchair and she's right we totally did..wasn't I a cute baby? hahahah]


Wow this sounds totally different then the original. His hair kinda looks better too I dunno. This is great. WOW that note totally sold it. LOVE IT.. LOVE HIM!! Randy thought he was original and bold and he could win the whole lot. Paula is blown away and she can’t sit down. Simon thought it was brave and it was amazing. YEAHH!!!
EDIT: I forgot to pick who was going home. I think the bottom three will be Chikeze, Ramiele, and Kristy Lee Cook and I don’t care which goes home haha